I've been terrified to post my portfolio for your critiques... but finally gritting my teeth and jumping in (eeeek!). I feel like I'm off to a good start, but still a little insecure (I gotta work on that, too!).
I'd like to know what you think, I realize that I need to show more work, and am slowly adding to the portfolio as I build new designs and dig up old ones.
My aim is to one day (after I've spent some more time here and totally learned my way around) become an elite designer, and I know that in addition to participating in the forum and community contests, a well developed and diverse portfolio is important. I hope that with your critiques and advice on how to improve, I can reach my goal.
Thanks in advance for your feedback!
Here's the link: Brandy Arnold: Graphic Design
Results 1 to 20 of 20
Thread: Portfolio critique
12-16-2009, 05:32 PM #1
12-16-2009, 06:33 PM #2
- Join Date
- Oct 2009
- City, State
- Paranaque Philippines / Virginia, USA
i can relate on "just recently showing-off works" -- im on the same page on that note! - lol -- and am trying to get my hands/mind wet again into the design pool! - LOL! (and yep, am def. insecure bout my works too LOOOL!)
i checked out your works - and i have to say - your designs (to me) is bold with a clean touch! -- my fav. amongst your logos is "everydaygreen" !!! yeah! i like the color and the "softness" of the style of font! but all in all -- your designs are bold and clear enough to understand on first-glance ....
since im still a beginner myself ... i cant give solid professional advice (yet-LOL! hopefully that will change *winks*) -- but what i can comment a little bit -- is -- for the kids menu --- maybe --- make instructions a little bit bigger size font so that the kids can read or practice to read =D
but snap gurl! i dig the "boldness + clarity" of your design style!
the best is yet to come ~
12-17-2009, 08:07 PM #3
Lots of original concepts and creative pieces, I'd say you're off to a great start.
I really like the "mini cities" design, it would also do a great banner for a website. Nice cute illustration on the "Beachside Critter Sitter" logo and your combination of font, color and layout works well in the "feather your nest" logo. The "Squid Roe" logo has a great concept but I might have used smoother curves for the tentacles.
Keep up the good work and I wish you all the best for the future ( and never stop enjoying yourself because that is what true design is all about : ).
12-18-2009, 11:48 AM #4
I'm not great at giving critiques on overall portfolios and why you don't see me comment offten in this section.. (my insecurities LOL)
I'd say overall you have a good style and have some versitility between illustrative and corportate design in your logos. I only had a few moments to quickly run through the images so I didn't get a chance to really dig into anything but an overall feeling of your work. I did see a couple kerning issues with in some of the lettering but nothing to obvious. This is the area I've been working on myself for the past 8 or so months.
I'm not a big fan of the squid roe type of art as it feels like it's something my 7yr old would do. But I understand it's a look that is on the popular side at the moment and why people are doing it.
Oh im not saying you draw like a 7yr old it's just that type of art (anyone does) that my kid can do. LOL
overall a solid start to with your portfolio.
Here is a post I put togeather when I was getting my portfolio togeather.
Last edited by Coy; 12-18-2009 at 11:50 AM.
12-18-2009, 06:55 PM #5
thank you all for taking the time to look at my portfolio and give me your feedback, I truly appreciate it.
Coy, I agree about the Squid Roe type of graphic. It has a very polarizing effect on people - you either love that style or hate it. It reminds me of the Tim Burton style, like in Nightmare Before Christmas. Luckily that particular design was for the back of a boat (bow or stern - i can't remember, HA, a boat owner would slap me for calling it the "back") so the only opinion that mattered was the client (no need to attract customers, etc). Had it been a business logo, I would have fought for a more universally attractive design.
Anyway, thanks again!Brandy
12-18-2009, 06:56 PM #6
ps - that darn kerning! I've got to work on that...Brandy
12-20-2009, 05:12 PM #7
I know, it's hard putting yourself out there, so good job for having the courage to do that! I think overall it's a good start (obviously need more examples, but you know that). I think you have some good solid ideas. I really like your illustration for Beach Side Critter Sitter. Did you draw all the illustrations in all your logos? My favorites are Packaging Solutions, Feather your Nest, Mini Cities, and Squid Row. One suggestion for Squid Row, I think it would look neat if you integrated the tentacles with the type and take out the black box. Maybe just make another layer of the text and make it white with an outline and place both layers of text over the tentacles. Or maybe just make the box a more interesting/abstract shape more similar to the tentacles. I actually really like the style of the illustration personally. All in all, pretty good! Just need to work on your type a bit.
12-20-2009, 07:39 PM #8
After reading everyone's comments, I think I'll spend some time reworking the Squid Roe logo (just for fun, as the client has already put it to use a few years ago). I, too, am a fan of the Tim Burton-esque style, so I think I'll keep the choppy tentacles, but great idea integrating it into the text... I've gotta try that!
Most of my previous design work was at design firms or at my current place of employment, so I either no longer have access to those files or could jeopardize my current job by posting work done at the office... Unfortunately some of my favorite work was done several years ago with a design firm that I worked with... wish i still had those logos to add to my portfolio... oh well, I've got my whole life to make more!
Thanks again for the feedback!Brandy
12-23-2009, 06:49 PM #9
So... reading through the forum, I've noticed a few different people post about how their application for ED was rejected the first time they applied, because of a weak portfolio, or not enough logos, etc...
I'm wondering if someone can take a look at my portfolio and let me know if it is strong enough, or if I need to add a lot more to it?
I know that the basis of a good portfolio is not necessarily quantity, but quality, but I do agree there is a necessity to show enough examples and variety to get your point as a designer across; and it's not a simple black and white answer such as: you must show 15 logos, 5 illustrations, etc...
I'm looking forward to applying soon, and want to make sure I have all my ducks in a row!
12-25-2009, 09:49 PM #10
I haven´t so much experience making logos,but as I think,the best one to me is Arianne´s boat logo (I like art decó feelings u use in)...
So cleany all designs showed in...
12-27-2009, 11:19 PM #11
- Join Date
- Dec 2009
I really like the active business solutions logo and bc. That one appealed to me personally.
12-27-2009, 11:53 PM #12
thanks a bunch!! I really appreciate you all taking the time to look at my portfolio and give me feedback!Brandy
01-29-2010, 09:55 PM #13
wow. all that just to spam for some roof repair (or whatever it is, I'm afraid to click the links)... i mean... seriously. Do these kinds of posts really work??Brandy
01-30-2010, 01:42 AM #14
I think what he was trying to say was GREAT LOGOS BRANDY! I just got to see them and I'm really enjoying your style. Keep it up.
01-30-2010, 11:48 PM #15
- Join Date
- Jan 2010
- City, State
- Montreal, Québec
Some nice work in there, contrary to the others i do like the feel of the squid roe logo
I like the simple and clean look of you portfolio but maybe you could change some little things on the main page to make it better
- Design yourself a logo (yeah yeah i know, not always easy...) or at least choose a better font
- Maybe align the logo and "about the artist" to the boxes
- Let it breathe, put some more margins on top and bottom of your name, put a tiny bit more between the boxes
- Put some better quality jpg on the main page, we can see the compression. Or export them in gif if they dont have many colors.
(i just realised it was a shown'd portfolio... can you edit the code on that thing?)
01-30-2010, 11:55 PM #16
I agree with you on all points... the header, the misalignment, the bitmapped/oversized images, the weird spacing... those things all irritate me to no end - but, it's a free portfolio site, so the only freedom I have is in what I upload into the image areas... unfortunately i can't change any of those other things!
thanks for taking a look and giving me your thoughts, I appreciate it!Brandy
01-31-2010, 02:01 PM #17
- Join Date
- Jan 2010
Brandy you are young and really talented. I'm sure that your enthusiasm can only evolve in good experiance.
Go ahead without esitation and good luck!
02-20-2010, 05:01 PM #18
- Join Date
- Feb 2010
- City, State
- Gold Coast, Queensland
Love your work, particularly your logo designs. I am going to show them to my highschool students who are presently attempting to create their first logo in Illustrator.
02-20-2010, 05:19 PM #19
02-21-2010, 11:24 AM #20
Glad to get a chance to look at your portfolio. You have some really good work. What you really need to improve on... is not so much illustrator as it is your type work. Be careful to not jumble words over one another or connect them for some reason. VERY rarely is a type fine as soon as you type it into the design. Use the spacing feature with illustrator and start too move letters closer together or farther away from each other. I think that will give you a great start.
As far as becoming an ED I think you have what it takes. Wanting to be critiqued is always the first step. Granted im not an ED yet but from comparing to other ED's I think you rank fine. Also, post some of your logo's mid work to be critiqued as well. Obviously going through a whole portfolio is hard and you miss or leave out some things you would have liked to say.
Overall you are a great illustrator and designer. I think with a few more designs and implementing some new ideas you can become even better!
Thanks for showing us your portfolio =)
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)